How to Opt Out of a Class Action Lawsuit: Rules, Deadlines and What You Give Up

How to Opt Out of a Class Action Lawsuit: Rules, Deadlines and What You Give Up

What a request for exclusion is, which class actions let you file one, and what leaving does to your own claim.

An envelope arrives. Inside is a notice telling you that a lawsuit you have never heard of has been filed on your behalf, that you are already a member of the class, and that a date in a few weeks decides something. Nothing in it asks you to sign up, which is the part that unsettles people. You were put in without being asked.

There are two separate decisions buried in that notice, and most pages on this subject run them together. One is whether to claim anything. The other is whether to stay in the class at all. Leaving is called opting out, and it is the only one of the two that is usually irreversible.

This article works from the rule that creates the right, Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and from the statute that sets the timetable around a settlement. It also covers the question nobody on the first page of search results answers: whether your class action lets you leave in the first place. Several kinds do not.

This is general information about court procedure and not legal advice about your case. The notice you were sent, and the lawyer you choose, come first.

What opting out actually is

The rule does not use the words opt out. It says request exclusion, and the difference is worth keeping, because the phrase in the notice will be the rule wording rather than the everyday one.

Two of the seven things a class notice must tell you are about leaving. Rule 23(c)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the notice to state “that the court will exclude from the class any member who requests exclusion”, and the next item requires it to state “the time and manner for requesting exclusion”. Both are in the rule because leaving is a real right, not a courtesy the lawyers extend.

The reason it matters is in the judgment paragraph. Rule 23(c)(3)(B) says that for a class certified under Rule 23(b)(3), the judgment must “include and specify or describe those to whom the Rule 23(c)(2) notice was directed, who have not requested exclusion, and whom the court finds to be class members”. Requesting exclusion is the mechanism that keeps you off that list. The whole point of the exercise is which side of a sentence in a future judgment your name lands on.

First find out whether your class lets you leave

This is the step the search results skip, and it decides everything else. The right to request exclusion is not a free standing right that belongs to every class member. It is attached to one subdivision of the rule.

Rule 23(b) describes three kinds of class action:

  • Rule 23(b)(1): separate individual suits would risk inconsistent standards of conduct for the defendant, or would as a practical matter dispose of the interests of absent members. The limited fund case is the familiar example.
  • Rule 23(b)(2): the defendant acted on grounds that apply generally to the class, so that “final injunctive relief or corresponding declaratory relief is appropriate respecting the class as a whole”. A case about changing a policy rather than paying money.
  • Rule 23(b)(3): common questions predominate over individual ones and a class action is superior to the alternatives. This is the damages class, and it is the one most consumer notices come from.

Now read the notice paragraph against that list. Rule 23(c)(2)(A) says that for a class certified under Rule 23(b)(1) or (b)(2), “the court may direct appropriate notice to the class”. May. Rule 23(c)(2)(B) then names two situations in one sentence: “any class certified under Rule 23(b)(3)”, and a class on which the court orders notice under Rule 23(e)(1) because it is “proposed to be certified for purposes of settlement under Rule 23(b)(3)”. In both of those the court “must direct to class members the best notice that is practicable under the circumstances”. Only that second paragraph carries the two exclusion items. The first one carries nothing about leaving at all.

That second limb is not a technicality, and it is probably the one you are holding. A great many class members never hear about the case until a settlement has been reached, and the class is then certified for settlement purposes only. The notice that lands on the mat in that situation is a Rule 23(e)(1) notice carrying Rule 23(c)(2)(B) content, which is why it has an exclusion deadline in it at all.

The judgment paragraph closes it. Rule 23(c)(3)(A) says that for a (b)(1) or (b)(2) class the judgment must “include and describe those whom the court finds to be class members”, with no carve out for anybody who asked to be let out. There is no carve out because there is no request to make.

The Supreme Court put the same point in one sentence in Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, 564 U.S. 338: “unlike (b)(1) and (b)(2) classes, the (b)(3) class is not mandatory; class members are entitled to receive the best notice that is practicable under the circumstances and to withdraw from the class at their option.”

This is the trap that catches people who read only the operative line. Rule 23(c)(2)(B)(v) reads like a universal right if you quote it on its own. The scope line at the top of the same paragraph, the one naming which classes it applies to, is what settles the question. Two class members holding notices that look alike can have opposite rights.

How to tell from the paperwork which one you have

  • The notice itself normally names the subdivision. Look for the phrase certified under Rule 23(b)(3), or the equivalent for (b)(1) or (b)(2), in the section describing the case.
  • If exclusion is available, the notice has to tell you how and by when, because the rule requires it. A notice with no exclusion section is usually telling you something by its silence.
  • Congress built the same signal into the official notice package. 28 U.S.C. 1715(b)(3) requires the defendant to serve state and federal officials with any notification to class members of “the members’ rights to request exclusion from the class action”, or, “if no right to request exclusion exists, a statement that no such right exists”.

Behind all of this sits a constitutional floor. In Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Shutts, 472 U.S. 797, the Supreme Court held that “due process requires at a minimum that an absent plaintiff be provided with an opportunity to remove himself from the class by executing and returning an opt out or request for exclusion form to the court”. The Court limited that holding, in a footnote, to class actions seeking to bind known plaintiffs on claims wholly or predominantly for money judgments, and said it intimated no view on other types, such as those seeking equitable relief. That limit is exactly why an injunction only class can be mandatory.

Find the deadline before you decide anything

Rule 23(c)(2)(B) makes the notice state seven things clearly and concisely. They are worth knowing because they tell you what the notice should contain, and therefore what to look for when it runs to nine pages:

  1. the nature of the action
  2. the definition of the class certified
  3. the class claims, issues, or defenses
  4. that a class member may enter an appearance through an attorney if the member so desires
  5. that the court will exclude from the class any member who requests exclusion
  6. the time and manner for requesting exclusion
  7. the binding effect of a class judgment on members under Rule 23(c)(3)

Item six is your deadline, and the rule does not set it. The judge does, case by case, in the order approving the notice. There is no national exclusion period and no standard number of days. The notice and the settlement website for your case are the only authority on it, and a date copied from an article about a different case is worth nothing.

The rule also allows notice by “United States mail, electronic means, or other appropriate means”, so an exclusion notice that arrives by email is not automatically a fake. Check it against the court docket rather than against your instinct about the delivery method.

How to request exclusion, step by step

Because the court sets the manner rather than the rule, these steps are about reading your notice correctly rather than following a national template.

  1. Find the exclusion section and copy it out. Address, deadline, and anything the notice says the request must contain. Those three items are the whole instruction set, and they come from the court order behind the notice.
  2. Check whether the deadline is a postmark date or a received by date. The rule leaves the manner to the court, so both exist. Treating a received by date as a postmark date loses the right entirely.
  3. Write a letter unless a form is supplied. A request normally identifies the case by name and number, identifies you by name and current address, says in terms that you want to be excluded from the class, and is signed and dated. The notice governs if it asks for more.
  4. One member, one request. The rule speaks of a member who requests exclusion, in the singular. If two people in a household are both class members, send two requests unless the notice says a joint request is accepted.
  5. Keep proof. A copy of what you sent and a mailing receipt. If the administrator has no record of your request later, your copy is the argument.
  6. If you have missed the date, ask anyway. Rule 23(c)(1)(C) says an order granting or denying certification “may be altered or amended before final judgment”, and whether a late request is accepted is a decision for the judge, not for the claims administrator. Asking late is worth more than assuming.

One thing a request for exclusion is not: a complaint about the deal. If what you want is for the court to hear why the settlement is bad, that is a separate step with separate rules, covered further down.

What you give up and what you keep

Opting out is a trade, and both sides of it are concrete.

What you give up

  • Any share of the settlement or the judgment, including anything the allocation plan would have paid you automatically without a claim form.
  • Class counsel. Their fees are dealt with under Rule 23(h), which lets the court award reasonable fees and nontaxable costs “authorized by law or by the parties’ agreement”, and a class member may object to that motion. Once you are out, none of that machinery is working on your behalf.
  • The claims process, which exists to turn a judgment into money without each member proving a case.
  • The court’s supervision of the deal. Rule 23(e)(2) lets a judge approve a settlement “only after a hearing and only on finding that it is fair, reasonable, and adequate”. Nobody reviews your private settlement that way.

What you keep

  • Your own claim, undiminished. Because Rule 23(c)(3)(B) reaches only the members who did not request exclusion, the class judgment does not bind you and the release in the settlement does not cover you.
  • The right to sue on your own schedule, in your own court, for what your own loss is actually worth.
  • The right to settle privately with the defendant on terms nobody has to approve.

The thing most people underestimate is what the first bullet of that second list costs to use. A claim you run yourself has to be proved element by element on its own evidence, which is a different job from filling in a claim form. Our guide to proving a medical malpractice claim sets out what that burden looks like in one field, and the shape of it carries over.

The deadline you cannot see: your own limitations period

A class action freezes a clock while it runs. Leaving the class raises the question of what happens to that clock, and it is the single most expensive thing to get wrong.

In American Pipe and Construction Co. v. Utah, 414 U.S. 538, the Supreme Court held that “the commencement of a class action suspends the applicable statute of limitations as to all asserted members of the class who would have been parties had the suit been permitted to continue as a class action”. Nine years later, in Crown, Cork and Seal Co. v. Parker, 462 U.S. 345, the Court extended that rule beyond people seeking to intervene, to class members who file their own separate actions after certification is denied.

The reasoning in the second case is the part worth reading if you are holding a notice. The Court reasoned that confining American Pipe to people who intervene would be inconsistent with its own reliance on American Pipe a few months later in Eisen v. Carlisle and Jacquelin, where it held that individual notice was required so that each class member could decide whether to opt out of the class “and thereby preserve his right to pursue his own lawsuit”. A class member would be unable to press that claim separately if the limitations period had expired while the class action was pending. The exclusion decision and the limitations clock are the same subject.

Read what those cases actually decided, though. Both arose where class certification had been denied, not where a member voluntarily left a certified class. Courts have carried the principle across to people who request exclusion, but that is a question answered court by court rather than by one national rule, and the answer can turn on which claim and which state you are in.

The practical version is short. Before you post an exclusion request, find two dates: the day your claim arose, and the last day your state allows a claim of that kind to be filed. If the second date is close, or has passed while the class action was pending, opting out can buy you an empty right. That is a question for a lawyer in your state, and it is worth the call before the exclusion deadline rather than after it.

Objecting is not opting out

These are different doors and they lead to different rooms. Opting out takes you outside the case. Objecting keeps you inside it and tells the judge the deal is not good enough.

Rule 23(e)(5)(A) says “any class member may object to the proposal if it requires court approval under this subdivision (e)”, and that the objection “must state whether it applies only to the objector, to a specific subset of the class, or to the entire class, and also state with specificity the grounds for the objection”. An objector stays a class member and stays bound by whatever the court finally approves. Objecting preserves nothing about your own right to sue.

Rule 23(e)(5)(B) deals with the objector who is in it for himself. Unless the court approves it after a hearing, “no payment or other consideration may be provided in connection with” forgoing or withdrawing an objection, or forgoing, dismissing or abandoning an appeal from a judgment approving the proposal. Worth knowing when that arrived and what it changed: the advisory committee notes to Rule 23 record that the 2018 amendment went in two directions at once. It dropped the older requirement that a court approve every withdrawal of an objection, on the view that an objector should be free to withdraw, and it extended the approval requirement for payments to cover appeals, because an objector’s appeal can hold a settlement up far longer than an objection in the district court.

If you object, these are the findings you are aiming at. Rule 23(e)(2) lets the court approve a proposal that would bind class members “only after a hearing and only on finding that it is fair, reasonable, and adequate”, and it sets four lettered factors for the judge to consider:

  1. whether the class representatives and class counsel have adequately represented the class
  2. whether the proposal was negotiated at arm’s length
  3. whether the relief provided for the class is adequate, which is the one factor with its own list underneath it: the costs, risks and delay of trial and appeal; the effectiveness of the proposed method of distributing relief, including how class member claims will be processed; the terms of any proposed award of attorney’s fees, including the timing of payment; and any agreement the parties had to identify under Rule 23(e)(3)
  4. whether the proposal “treats class members equitably relative to each other”

Those four lettered factors are a checklist for reading a settlement you dislike. The last one is the one that most often carries an objection: an allocation that pays one group of members well and another group almost nothing is a question the rule puts squarely in front of the judge. The list itself is recent. It came in with the same 2018 amendment, and the committee notes say the goal was not to displace the factor lists each circuit had built up over thirty or forty years but to focus the court on the core concerns, so your circuit may still have a longer list on top.

The second chance the rule sometimes gives you

Many class members meet the case twice, once when the class is certified and again when a settlement is proposed, and wonder whether the first deadline was the only one.

Rule 23(e)(4) answers it: “if the class action was previously certified under Rule 23(b)(3), the court may refuse to approve a settlement unless it affords a new opportunity to request exclusion to individual class members who had an earlier opportunity to request exclusion but did not do so.”

May, not must. A second exclusion window is a thing judges have the power to insist on, not a thing you are entitled to. If your notice offers one, it is because the court asked for it in that case. Plan around the deadline you have in writing and treat anything else as a bonus.

Note also what the sentence is built on: it only applies where the class was previously certified under Rule 23(b)(3). The same subdivision again. If you are reading this part of the rule to work out your rights, you have already answered the question about which class you are in, or you have skipped it.

Why nothing happens for months after the deadline

People send an exclusion request, or file a claim, and then hear nothing for the better part of a year. Part of that delay is written into a statute rather than into the lawyers’ diaries.

  • 28 U.S.C. 1715(b) requires each defendant participating in a proposed class settlement to serve a notice package on the appropriate federal official and on the appropriate state official of each state where a class member lives, no later than 10 days after the proposed settlement is filed in court.
  • Section 1715(d) then says an order giving final approval “may not be issued earlier than 90 days after the later of the dates on which the appropriate Federal official and the appropriate State official are served”. The ninety day wait is a floor under the whole timetable.
  • Section 1715(e)(1) gives that requirement teeth from the member side: a class member “may refuse to comply with and may choose not to be bound by a settlement agreement or consent decree” if the member demonstrates that the required official notice was not provided. Section 1715(e)(2) narrows that where notice did reach the right officials.

That last point is not an exclusion route and should not be treated as one. It is a defense raised later by somebody the settlement is being enforced against, not a letter you can send instead of a request for exclusion.

Section 1715 is not an old provision. It was added by the Class Action Fairness Act, Public Law 109-2, on 18 February 2005, and it applies to civil actions commenced on or after that date. An account of class settlement timing written before 2005 does not describe the system you are in.

State court runs on a different rulebook

Rule 23 governs federal court. A great many class actions are filed in state court, every state has its own class procedure, and they are not all copies of the federal rule. Carrying a federal assumption into a state case is the easiest way to be wrong about your own rights.

California is a clear illustration of the difference. California Rules of Court, rule 3.766 does not attach an exclusion right to a category of class. It says that on certification the court “must make an order determining” a list of things, and the second item on that list is “Whether class members may exclude themselves from the action”. The judge decides, in that case, whether exclusion is available at all. Read that for what it says and not for more than it says. California damages classes commonly do carry exclusion rights. The difference is where the right comes from: in federal court it is attached to the subdivision the class was certified under, and in California it comes out of the order the judge makes in your case. The document to read is therefore not the same document.

Rule 3.766(d) then sets the contents of the notice, but only on a condition: “If class members are to be given the right to request exclusion from the class”, the notice must include a brief explanation of the case, “A statement that the court will exclude the member from the class if the member so requests by a specified date”, a procedure for requesting exclusion, a statement that the judgment “whether favorable or not, will bind all members who do not request exclusion”, and a statement that a member who does not request exclusion may enter an appearance through counsel.

That is one state, named, and no claim is being made here about the other forty nine. The method is what transfers. Find the class action rule for the court named on your notice, and read the part that says which classes the rule applies to and who decides, not only the part that lists what the notice must say.

Opting in is a different system, and it exists

Some notices say nothing will happen unless you return a form. That is not a badly drafted class notice. It is usually a different kind of case.

The default in American class procedure is exclusion rather than joining. In Shutts the Supreme Court rejected the argument that the Due Process Clause requires absent plaintiffs to affirmatively opt in, holding instead that notice with an explanation of the right to opt out satisfies due process. The Court also recorded in that case that 3,400 of the 28,100 class members returned the request for exclusion, which it treated as evidence that the procedure is not a formality.

The clearest statutory exception runs the other way. A collective action for unpaid wages under the Fair Labor Standards Act is built on consent: 29 U.S.C. 216(b) says “no employee shall be a party plaintiff to any such action unless he gives his consent in writing to become such a party and such consent is filed in the court in which such action is brought”. In a wage collective action, doing nothing leaves you out. In a Rule 23(b)(3) class, doing nothing leaves you in. Same envelope, opposite consequence.

Reasons people leave, and reasons they wish they had not

There is no formula here, and anybody offering one with a number attached is guessing. What there is, is a set of things you can read for yourself before the deadline.

Points toward leaving

  • Your loss is far larger than a share can be. A class settlement divides one pot among everybody who claims. If your loss sits far above whatever a per member share can come to under the allocation plan, the arithmetic is against staying.
  • You already have a lawyer and a case. Somebody with a filed individual action usually has a reason for it, and the release would end it.
  • The release is wider than the claim. Read the released claims definition in the settlement agreement rather than the headline. A settlement about a billing practice can release claims you had not connected to it.
  • Your injury is still developing. Signing away future claims for a present payment is a decision that cannot be unwound.

Points toward staying

  • The cost of running a case alone. Filing fees, discovery and expert evidence are the reason the class device exists.
  • You lose the fee arrangement. Class counsel are paid under Rule 23(h) out of the fund or by the defendant. Your own lawyer is paid by you or out of your recovery.
  • Your limitations period keeps running. Covered above, and it is the quiet one.
  • Proof. The class case has already built a record. Starting alone means building one.

A note on money, because the question always comes next. There is no public register of class action outcomes to average, and settlements distribute under formulas written into the settlement agreement for that case, which is a document you can read. Any figure circulating as a typical class action payout is not traceable to a source. Read the allocation plan, work out which tier you fall in, and compare that with your own loss. That is a calculation. An average is not.

Making sure the notice is real

Fake settlement notices exist, and the exclusion deadline is a useful pressure point for somebody running one. A few checks separate them.

  • A genuine notice names a court, a case name and a case number. For a federal case those three can be checked against the docket through the judiciary PACER case lookup service, which is the same record the lawyers are filing into.
  • A genuine notice never asks you to pay anything to stay in, to claim, or to be excluded, and it does not need your bank login to let you out.
  • Use the exclusion address printed in the notice, not one found in a search result or sent to you separately in another message.
  • Government refund programs are a separate thing from private class actions and are run by the agency itself rather than by a settlement administrator. The Federal Trade Commission refund programs page lists the refund programs that agency is running and the cases they came out of, which is where to check rather than taking a message about one on trust.

If the notice checks out and the deadline is close, the order of work is: find the subdivision, find the deadline, find the released claims definition, find your own limitations date. Those four readings tell you more than any comparison of other people’s outcomes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if I opt out of a class action lawsuit?

You are removed from the class, so the judgment does not bind you. Rule 23(c)(3)(B) says the judgment in a Rule 23(b)(3) class covers only the members who did not request exclusion. You give up any share of the settlement and you give up class counsel, who are working on the class case rather than on yours. What you keep is your own claim, which you then have to bring yourself, inside your own limitations period, with your own lawyer and your own evidence.

What happens if I do nothing in a class action lawsuit?

Doing nothing keeps you in the class. Under Rule 23(c)(3) the judgment binds the members who did not request exclusion whether or not it is favorable, so you lose the right to sue separately on the claims the settlement releases. Staying in is also not the same as being paid. Where a settlement pays on a claim form rather than automatically, that form carries its own separate deadline, so silence can leave you bound by the result and holding nothing.

Are you automatically part of a class action lawsuit?

Yes. If you fall inside the class definition in the certification order you are a member without applying, because Rule 23(c)(1)(B) makes the court define the class rather than collect sign ups. Whether you can leave depends on the subdivision the class was certified under. A Rule 23(b)(3) class carries a right to request exclusion. A class certified under Rule 23(b)(1) or Rule 23(b)(2) generally does not.

Why would you exclude yourself from a class action lawsuit?

The usual reason is size. A class settlement divides one pot across everybody who claims, so a person whose loss sits far above what a share can come to may do better alone. Other reasons are a case already filed with a lawyer, an injury that is still developing, and a release written wider than the claim being settled. Against all of that sit the cost of running a case alone and the fact that your own limitations period keeps running.

Is it better to opt out of a class action lawsuit?

There is no general answer, and any average payout figure offered as one is not traceable to a source. Work it out from four things you can read: whether the class allows exclusion at all, how the settlement agreement says the money will be divided, how wide the released claims definition is, and how much time is left on the limitations period for your own claim.

Should I opt in to a class action lawsuit?

In most class actions there is nothing to opt in to. American class procedure runs on exclusion rather than on joining, and in Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Shutts the Supreme Court rejected the argument that due process requires absent plaintiffs to opt in rather than be treated as members unless they opt out. The main exception is a collective action for unpaid wages, where 29 U.S.C. 216(b) says no employee is a party plaintiff unless written consent is filed with the court.

0 comments on “How to Opt Out of a Class Action Lawsuit: Rules, Deadlines and What You Give Up”Add yours →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *